SpaceX’s New Legal Battle
SpaceX has filed a lawsuit against a California agency after it rejected the company’s proposal to ramp up rocket launches from the state. Last week, the California Coastal Commission (CCC) decided against increasing SpaceX’s launches from 36 to 50 per year. This decision came despite support from the U.S. Air Force, who emphasized the need for these launches for national security.
Claims of Political Bias
In its lawsuit, SpaceX alleges that the CCC engaged in “naked political discrimination.” Some commissioners referenced CEO Elon Musk’s political activities as influencing their decision. SpaceX is now tasked with proving in court that the CCC’s choice was heavily impacted by these political views.
The Issue of Legal Authority
A key argument in this case is whether launch activities at defense bases are deemed federal or private. SpaceX and the Air Force assert these operations fit under federal activities, allowing them to bypass certain state regulations. The commission disagrees, stating that SpaceX’s commercial activities necessitate a coastal development permit.
The Split Decision
The CCC’s final vote on this matter was close, with a 6-4 outcome against SpaceX’s proposal. Some commissioners expressed concerns about the private nature of the launches, indicating these should require additional permits. Others pointed out Musk’s political actions as a factor in their vote.
Next Steps for SpaceX
Moving forward, the CCC will reconsider launch increases, with SpaceX aiming to push that number to 100 launches per year. Given the divided views among the commissioners, this next decision could prove crucial.